
Today in Columbus I visited the Easton Mall, and the included
Barnes & Noble bookstore, and noticed in philosophy (one stack vs. six stacks for Christian stuff) a book called
The Parallax View (Short Circuits) by Slajov Zizek, a professor of philosophy at Ljubljana University in Slovenia. It got my attention because a) I have a friend doing her PhD there in philosophy, and; b) the observation that the universe is different depending on where one stands to look at it has been gnawing at me lately.
My family (mother & siblings) are devout Christians and I'm not. What the universe is to them has nothing at all to do with the universe I live in. And while that is, for me, the most obvious case, it's also true that the universe of any New Yorker will be different than that of any San Diegan. Following this to its logical conclusion the universe is different for each individual. The old question of whether strawberries taste the same to everyone can never be answered.
So...how does this apply to photography and why are you bringing it up at all, you ask? It's a troubling answer I think. A photographer limits the physical perspective and reach of a photograph by where the lens is, what lens it is, other techie shit and by the framing of the photograph. This forces all who look at the photograph to see the view through one of my eyes. Nevertheless, it's certain that even shown exactly the same view through the photograph, viewers see different things.
That picture above shows a young woman masturbating (Chantel in Winnipeg last November). Most would agree with that. There may be enough clues to place the scene in a hotel room. Beyond that cultural factors start kicking in and judgements as to the morality of masturbating, possible invasion of privacy, possible uses or intentions of the photograph are made, and each viewer makes them. And I believe viewers each make different judgements because each viewer lives in a different universe.
The truth is, only I know what was really happening there and I'm not telling. And if I did tell, it would be influenced by my own view of the universe and could not even be communicated to those with radically different universes.
See what happens when I'm left alone in a bookstore.
I also met Chip Willis (see his guest appearance below) and Ferhat, another fine photographer, ate Turkish food and talked for hours. When Ferhat moves away from his fashion work long enough to photograph a nude woman in a hotel room, I'd be delighted to show it here.